We ordered an Antipasta salad without anchovies (prosciutto, soppressata, salami, provolone, artichokes, roasted peppers, tomatoes, olives, and onions) to start. It's definitely a good size to split into 2 small salads. However, we were used to antipastas being served with dressing already on it and we were given the choice of dressing which I think just confused us. Tried the olive oil and balsamic vinegar which wasn't the right choice. It was $13.95 for the salad.
We also ordered a Sicilian square-pan pizza. It is probably their best value. For $14.95 you get a one-size-fits all (and then some) cheese pizza. We added pepperoni to ours for an extra $2.25. You get 16 huge pieces. Well, it's not that they are huge but they are DENSE. Two pieces and you're full. I think we got like 6-7 meals out of this thing. Check out our leftovers:
Website and menu: http://www.carlocasalinga.net/
Speed: Quite fast. We had just finished our salad when the pizza was coming out and our service was amazing - our drinks never ran low.
Price: $7.95-$23.95/plate
Hours: Mon—Thurs: 4:30pm—9pm; Fri/Sat: 4:30pm—10pm, 5pm-10pm; Sun: 5pm-9pm
Overall: 5/5